Why don’t trees freeze and burst in the winter like cold pipes?

When liquid water freezes, it expands as the water molecules spread out to form a solid crystalline lattice. If the freezing water is contained in a closed vessel, such as a metal pipe, it can press hard on the sides as it expands, causing the container to burst.

Frost cracks are longitudinal openings that can run the entire length of the trunk, often extend deep into the wood, and permanently damage a tree. In wintertime, the tree may even look like it’s splitting in half! Then warmer weather comes, and the crack seems to close, repeating this process annually. Over time, frost cracks may even develop a raised area where callus tissue develops in an attempt to close over the wound, only to reopen again next winter. (Photo credit: Wisconsin Dept of Natural Resources)

Trees contain water that is transported throughout the tree by the phloem and xylem, which we can think of as pipes.

Trees are cold hardy because of many factors. In preparation for winter, many trees reduce the amount of water held in their tissue. They usually enter a dormant state to survive cold winters. Some trees, such as maple trees, produce more sugar. When this sugar dissolves in the water, it lowers the freezing point of the fluid. Unlike plumbing pipes, tree tissue is somewhat flexible; as water in the channels freezes and expands, the tree’s tissue can stretch somewhat.

Trees can suffer damage during periods of cold winter nights followed by warm sunny days. The bark alternately contracts with freezing temperatures and expands on warm days. The alternating freezing and thawing temperatures can result in a vertical crack called a “frost crack.” This often happens during late winter or early spring. The formation of a frost crack can be accompanied by a loud noise, like a gunshot sound. But the trees don’t “explode” in the in subzero weather.

Dangerous winter weather for trees are storms that lead to heavy snow and ice accumulating on the trees. The weight of frozen precipitation can put enormous stress on tree limbs, causing them to break and fall.

Steve Ackerman and Jonathan Martin, professors in the UW-Madison department of atmospheric and oceanic sciences, are guests on WHA radio (970 AM) at noon the last Monday of each month. Send them your questions at stevea@ssec.wisc.edu or jemarti1@wisc.edu.

Category: Climate, Seasons

Comments Off on Why don’t trees freeze and burst in the winter like cold pipes?

Comments are closed.